| 1 | Bristol town (southeast) | $119,219 |
| 2 | Millersburg town (north) | $106,818 |
| 3 | Nappanee city (north-northeast) | $104,357 |
| 4 | Middlebury town (west) | $102,328 |
| 5 | Middlebury town (east) | $98,906 |
| 6 | Millersburg town (south) | $95,250 |
| 7 | Vistula CDP (northwest) | $95,165 |
| 8 | Wakarusa town (northwest) | $88,558 |
| 9 | New Paris CDP (south) | $87,206 |
| 10 | Dunlap CDP (south-southeast) | $86,146 |
| 11 | Simonton Lake CDP (west-northwest) | $86,042 |
| 12 | Wakarusa town (southeast) | $84,357 |
| 13 | Vistula CDP (southeast) | $82,961 |
| 14 | Simonton Lake CDP (north-northwest) | $81,339 |
| 15 | Elkhart city (northeast) | $81,303 |
| 16 | Bristol town (north-northwest) | $80,565 |
| 17 | New Paris CDP (northwest) | $79,396 |
| 18 | Wakarusa town (south-southwest) | $78,333 |
| 19 | Wakarusa town (north-northwest) | $75,357 |
| 20 | Bristol town (west-southwest) | $74,835 |
| 21 | Dunlap CDP (east) | $74,375 |
| 22 | New Paris CDP (northeast) | $73,938 |
| 23 | Simonton Lake CDP (east-northeast) | $73,563 |
| 24 | Goshen city (west) | $70,993 |
| 25 | Dunlap CDP (southeast) | $68,843 |
| 26 | Simonton Lake CDP (southwest) | $64,167 |
| 27 | Simonton Lake CDP (south) | $64,156 |
| 28 | Goshen city (west-southwest) | $61,507 |
| 29 | Bristol town (northeast) | $61,016 |
| 30 | Goshen city (south-southeast) | $60,608 |
| 31 | Dunlap CDP (northwest) | $57,827 |
| 32 | Goshen city (east-northeast) | $56,667 |
| 33 | Nappanee city (south-southwest) | $56,020 |
| 34 | Simonton Lake CDP (north-northeast) | $54,861 |
| 35 | Elkhart city (southeast) | $52,094 |
| 36 | Goshen city (east-southeast) | $47,740 |
| 37 | Elkhart city (north-northwest) | $46,438 |
| 38 | Dunlap CDP (west-northwest) | $45,581 |
| 39 | Elkhart city (west-southwest) | $44,980 |
| 40 | Simonton Lake CDP (southeast) | $44,231 |
| 41 | Dunlap CDP (north) | $41,609 |
| 42 | Goshen city (northwest) | $41,557 |
| 43 | Elkhart city (east) | $41,264 |
| 44 | Elkhart city (southwest) | $37,355 |
| 45 | Dunlap CDP (west-southwest) | $32,889 |